The question, “Do half-tons have better reliability than heavy-duty versions,” is a slippery slope. So we’ll try to answer, but we’ll start by saying “it depends”. There are many more factors that go into what makes a truck a truck than what you will do with it.
What are the reliability trade-offs between diesel and gas engines?
Will you have to tow a trailer or boat on a regular basis? Are you looking for something to haul your family’s loads and weekend loads? Because in some cases you will need a diesel engine, which adds a certain complexity to the purchase. But the more complex it is, the more error there is.
and/or replacement.
That’s why we say “it depends”. A gas engine used in regular transportation will not hold up as well as a diesel. But the half-ton diesel is a personal preference, but it comes with additional maintenance and costs. So it is a game of mix between preference, withdrawal duties, and expenses.
Do these recalls indicate truck reliability?
Evaluating recalls over the past three years for gas engines versus diesel engines, it’s a mixed bag. The winner is, with no recalls for the 2500 and 3500 trucks, and only one truck in 2020 for fuel pump problems. The Ram 2500 has been showing recalls for transmissions three years in a row, with an ECM problem last year, and fuel pump problems in 2020. For the Ram 1500, for the past three years, there has been a fuel pump recall every year.
Ford’s F-250 has been recalled in 2020, as has the F-150. An automatic transmission recall was also issued for the F-150 in 2021. In 2021, the F-250 was recalled for diesel engine fuel filter leaking issues. Generally, problems with engines and transmissions occur in the first three years, and then once the mileage exceeds 100,000 to 150,000 miles.
What do consumer websites say about truck reliability?
Reviews from consumer websites such as Consumer Reports and JD Power favor heavy trucks over half a ton. But again, reliability is only a certain piece of the total pie. Ultimately, compiling a checklist of your wants, needs, and questions is the first step.
Then, head to your local dealership to see everything to check off your list. Hopefully, the seat of your pants, your gut feeling, and the amount you want to pay will lead you to a good decision.
